The 20" Demarco of Brooklyn is the best pizza. I'm not a big pizza person...at all. I'll eat a sandwich instead of pizza from any other place. This is the only pizza I eat with joy in my heart. LOL!!! But really. The only negative is the Ceasar dressing has changed. It used to be thick and now it's like water. still has a good enough flavor, but I prefer the thicker consistency.
N
Nychelle H
9 contributions
Liked
• 5/6/26
• DoorDash order
Ordered the 16" Triple Pepperoni Jamfest, pizza was ok, it was kinda cold tbh and I live under 2 miles from the location. My Andolini's Signature Salad had a container that included 1 single sliced strawberry, a $16 salad!! One sliced strawberry.... talk about shrinkflation. That was not a $16 salad. Wouldn't order via DoorDash again. Disappointed. Garlic knots and Caesar Salad were good but again, worth $16? Not really. Delivery Driver was excellent.
L
Lindsay B
1 contributions
Loved
• 11/25/23
• DoorDash order
20" Pizzas are huge! High end pizza that tastes like your in Italy, not like delivery. Cinco de Cuatro was perfectly hearty and spicy. Hoboken was a fun change up with white sauce, garlic, and meatballs. Yummy!
A
Aaron K
4 contributions
Loved
• 3/29/25
• DoorDash order
Mariano pesto was awesome as always! One of the most uniquely flavored pizzas ever. You can truly tell that Andolinis uses quality ingredients not your typical restaurant supply oils, flours and such. The salad was fresh and bright not a wilted bowl of lettuce vein like most places. The only complaint is that the pizzas arrived warm, not hot. Hard to expect piping hot when you live over 10 min away.
P
Patrick B
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/5/24
• DoorDash order
The pizza was absolutely delicious, however I didn't get all my toppings, and one of the toppings I asked for was VERY limited. Its bad enough you have to pay full price ($2) for a topping like balsamic glaze on half the 20" Custom / Cheese Pizza (IMO toppings like that should be cheaper), but they did't put it on the pizza. I also asked for cherry tomatoes, but most piec only at 2-3 halves on them. I would've given 5 stars if they included all toppings and a few more tomatoes. But, the pizza was still very good. The only other criticism I could give is it could've used a little more sauce.
