Long-fermented dough, Wisconsin mozzarella, California tomatoes, and a master pizzaiolo. We're a neighborhood pizzeria that specializes in New York-style pizza with traditional toppings.
FINALLY. A pizza in DC worth the money and carbs. Delicious! I ordered the cheese pie, margherita pie, and pepperoni pie. Every guest smashed these pizzas. SO good. Coming from NYC, I had all but given up on finding good pizza in DC. Andy's Pizza delivered solid NYC-style classics. The sauce was bright and SAVORY--not ketchup-y and sweet (which is the downfall of every "to-go style" pizza in DC outside of Duccini's ludicrous jumbo slice). If delivery pies were this spot-on, I can't wait to try a pedestrian NYC-style slice of this cheese pizza. I bet the crust will be crispy, and I'll be able to fold it in half on a white paper plate--just as it should be. This will be my ONLY place to order pizza, here on out.
B
Braden H
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/8/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza was great, solid 4/5, but avoid the salads. Not because the Caesar salad was bad, but because it was tiny and overpriced. ~$10 for a tiny side salad. Get your pizza from here and your salad at your neighborhood grocery store for $3.
D
Dionne W
Emerging Expert • 29 contributions
Loved
• 11/2/25
• DoorDash order
I got a 3 slices for a great price. The Caesar Salad was fresh and the portion size was perfect. I would definitely order again.
S
Samantha F
14 contributions
Loved
• 4/20/23
• DoorDash order
The Cheese Pie with extra cheese is our new go-to comfort food. Simple, yet delicious. Pretty large too so its well worth the money.
S
Shoshanna F
2 contributions
Loved
• 3/15/25
• DoorDash order
We ordered pizza from Andy's Pizza after a long day of site seeing. We got one cheese and one pepperoni pie. The pizza was delicious but the pies were very big, we probably only needed one pizza for the 4 of us!
