Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
4.6(2k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(2k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am - 9:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Pizza, Wings & Salad Bundle
$52.40
Original Wings
$15.10+
Create Your Own 16" Pizza
$26.20
•96% (25)
#1 Most liked
The Square Margherita 12"
$28.85
•90% (10)
Create Your Own 12" Pizza
$22.30
•100% (17)
Create Your Own 12" Gluten-Free Pizza
$28.85
Reviews2k+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
M
Marie-Denise C
Local Expert • 60 contributionsLiked
• 12/8/25The sandwich was good very large size
But I will say I've gone to the Anthony's in commack and they have the lunch special sandwich and soup I love that combo I love the soup!!! You should put that on your menu and the size of the sandwich is perfect.
Definitely the best Italian tuna I've had that's my go to sandwich but I need the soup to go with it!! Thank you
C
Courtney M
Local Expert • 21 contributionsLoved
• 10/2/25We order from DoorDash multiple times a week, so we’re very familiar with the limitations many restaurants have, especially when it comes to adding special instructions. Usually, that means having to call the restaurant directly to request something simple, like dressing on the side or a minor modification that isn’t available through the app. More often than not, even after calling, the request is either ignored or met with an extra charge.
That was not the case with Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza.
I spoke with Rafay at the store, and the level of service I received was so outstanding it inspired me to write this review entirely based on that experience. It was genuinely exceptional.
Honestly, even if the pizza had been the worst I’ve ever had (which it wasn’t), I would still order from here again solely because of the amazing service
PS- the pizza was fantastic , and those hot peppers pack a punch with every bite. The family bundle is well worth the money. The salad was fresh without a single piece of wilted lettuce, the knots are fluffy with a perfect ratio of garlic. 
P
Patricia F
2 contributionsLoved
• 4/23/25Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza in Woodbury has the most delicious food!! The eggplant dish and each and every pizza is awesome! The meatballs are the best! Everything is! The manager and waiter staff couldnt be more welcoming and nice! It's always such a great vibe there too. A definite five stars! Enjoy!
P
Paige W
2 contributionsDidn't like
• 8/8/24Cauliflower pizza was so burnt we could not eat it. Let DoorDash know and they gave us $5 credit for a $20+ pizza
A
Andrew K
2 contributionsDidn't like
• 5/9/26It was one singular meatball. For that amount of money there should be at least three.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
NEW! Specials
Bundles
Lunch Specials Starting at $9.99
All lunch specials are served with your choice of Fountain Beverage or Iced Tea. Available Monday through Friday until 3pm.
Lunch
Available Monday-Friday until 3pm
Wings
Starters & Salads
Pasta & Meatballs
16" Pizzas
Our coal-fired pizzas are well-done and may feature a crust with our signature char.
12" Pizzas
Our coal-fired pizzas are well-done and may feature a crust with our signature char.
12" Gluten Free Pizzas
Not recommended for guests with Celiac Disease as pizzas may be exposed to gluten during the preparation process. Certain toppings may contain gluten. Our coal-fired pizzas are well-done and may feature a crust with our signature char.