This was my first time ordering from Anthony's & the Calzone I ordered was excellent. I was glad I only ordered one for my mom & I to split. But honestly, it was big enough to feed 4. Definitely worth the price. I WILL be ordering from here again.
E
Evan T
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/4/24
• DoorDash review
Pizza was good but highly recommend not ordering the large Italian salad. $11 and it included 4- count em FOUR slices of pepperoni, a few olives, and a tiny bit of cheese. I had to dig through my own cupboards to dress it up and make it decent. I will say the quality was fresh but the amount of toppings was absurd- basically just lettuce. Feel ripped off and would really like a refund for it.
L
Luke D
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/21/25
• DoorDash order
Is it NY style pizza? Yes. Is it good NY style pizza? Eh, it's okay. Take it from an actual NY'er. I was excited to find a place that might have pizza like home. But it's definitely not worth the price you pay. A good plain pie from the city doesn't cost this much. Price aside, the pizza is okay. The cheese tears a little too easily though. It should tear, but not as much as it does with this pizza. Wouldn't order again unless it's cheaper.
C
Camille N
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/27/26
• DoorDash order
alfredo tasted old and baked ziti tasted like barley any tomato sauce. not worth the $50
M
Matt K
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/2/26
• DoorDash order
I give raving reviews when deserved. This was the most bland, awful, not eatable food I've paid for. Plus the extra cost for bread sticks, which were just as bad, don't ever order it. For pasta go elsewhere.