Upon taking the first bite of Anthony’s signature Super Beef, the most immediate sensation is the delicious combination of tender roast beef paired with a tangy BBQ sauce. The flavors meld beautifully at first, allowing the beef’s rich, savory essence to come through while being enhanced by the sweet and slightly smoky barbecue sauce.
As you progress through the sandwich, additional layers of flavor and texture start to unfold. The onion roll, which at first acts as a subtle vehicle for the beef, begins to contribute its own distinct notes. The gentle sweetness of the onion roll complements the roast beef, and the mayonnaise adds a creaminess that contrasts nicely with the meat’s texture. Together, these elements create a fuller, more nuanced experience as you move through the sandwich.
One of the more enjoyable surprises comes from the slight crunch in the roll. Whether it’s from being toasted just right or having the perfect balance of moisture from the sauces and toppings, this texture adds a satisfying layer to each bite. That crunch elevates the sandwich, keeping it from becoming overly soft, which often happens with large, sauce-heavy sandwiches.
Altogether, the Super Beef is a well-balanced sandwich, with the BBQ sauce and beef leading the way, but the onion roll, mayo, and textural contrast rounding out the experience. The flavors build progressively, making it a sandwich that stays interesting from first bite to last.
Overall Score: 8.4/10
With robust flavors and well-executed contrasts in both taste and texture, Anthony’s Super Beef stands out as a delicious take on the classic roast beef sandwich. A slight enhancement in the balance of BBQ and mayo might push it closer to perfection, but as is, it’s a strong contender in the world of roast beef sandwiches.
F
Food Critic E
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 8/29/25
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delicious! The FRIED OREOS are to die for. The SM STEAK CH CALZON is the perfect amount of cheese and steak blend. Great, fresh, good size, would order a million times over.
M
Michelle p
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/19/26
• DoorDash order
2 super beef 3 way, junior beef 3 way, fries, rings.. every single bite of every item was AMAZING! The beef is so tender! The roll is perfectly toasted! The sauce is tangy and the Mayo and cheese is just excellent! The rings are light and crispy and the fries are just fantastic! Everything arrived hot and crispy.
Y
Yvette A
2 contributions
Liked
• 1/23/26
• DoorDash order
The sandwich I ordered was absolutely wonderful! I opted for the 'Junior' beef, and honestly, if this is the small size, I can only imagine how generous the regular portion must be.
The delivery was incredibly fast, and the quality of the food was top-notch. A special thank you to Hector, who went above and beyond by delivering my meal directly to my room where I’m staying. It made my afternoon so much easier. Thank you for the fantastic food and the even better service!"
O
Olivia T
1 contributions
Liked
• 11/13/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was great minus the steak tip dinner. It was fatty and tasteless. Took one bite and wouldn't stopped eating. Has enough other food to supplement dinner and everything else had great taste and portions, so overall the meal wasn't horrible, just the steak tips were
