amazing!I'm quite a connoisseur of pizza. This one was beautifully made. Meatballs were sliced thicker than New York style, and it was pleasant! Sauce is slightly sweeter than other styles. perfectly baked and just what we needed tonight
D
Daphne B
2 contributions
Loved
• 5 days ago
• DoorDash order
I'm not a huge fan of old forge Sicilian. However, the lasagna, and the soup that I ordered in this delivery was some of the best I've ever had. Not only did it come piping hot, but the extras that I was able to add, including the meat meatballs were top-notch. Will order again.
G
Gina B
Local Expert • 45 contributions
Liked
• 3/30/26
• DoorDash order
Excellent taste, high quality meats, fresh vegetables, and fresh food , followed directions to tea. Perfect portions and will definitely order again!!
L
Lori F
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/4/26
• DoorDash order
The coconut shrimps sauce was like a watered down duck sauce with no flavor. The crab stuffed portabela mushroom was way too salty to eat.
K
Katie B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/9/26
• DoorDash order
Worst Old Forge pizza I've ever had. Completely undercooked and soggy. Sauce to cheese ratio was improper leaving the pizza completely soggy. Not the Arcaro of the past.
