Excellent!!! The dough is sweet and the toppings are the perfect amount. My 5 yr old loves the Athenian (Medium) and usually only eats cheese pizza. I added ricotta to the Athenian (Medium) and this really makest perfect. This is my new pizza place for sure.
E
Evan W
Emerging Expert • 25 contributions
Loved
• 12/23/24
• DoorDash order
It's my first order from here so I'm not sure why they put the ricotta on after cooking. It would have been much better cooked but it was still 5 stars! One review said the crust was sweet, I think they meant the sauce. Outstanding pizza and you can't beat the value. Place down the street charges $50 for this pie.
J
Jennifer M
10 contributions
Loved
• 6/30/25
• DoorDash order
The Cheese Pizza - Small 10'' (4 Slices)was seriously the best pizza I've had in a millenia. The Wings - 6 Pieces, however, weren't all that. They should have been cooked a bit longer because the drumsticks were tough. Still, I gave 5 stars because of how good the pizza was.
C
Christian S
1 contributions
Liked
• 10/23/22
• DoorDash order
Athens Pizza has been my fav pizza place for a while but lately it seems like the quality is very hit or miss, either toppings are wrong or there will be like 5 banana peppers on an XL pizza. Tonight my cheese bread was somehow mangled and the marinara very watery. I'll continue to order because when it hits it hits but there seems to be a little less of that these days.
J
Jennifer M
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/23/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered theCheese Pizza - Medium 12'' (6 Slices)& it's very good. However, Athens Pizza consistently ruins the Mozzarella Sticks - 5 Pieces. It's always so over cooked to the point of being burned. One of the cheese sticks didn't even have cheese in it. My guess is that it was cooked at such a high temperature that it all melted out. Frankly, I'm just going to give Athens Pizza a rest for a long time.
