Lots of noodles, hardly any sauce. I had to add water to make me sauce. If ordering, make sure to add an extra side of sauce.
K
Karen K
Emerging Expert • 31 contributions
Liked
• 2/13/26
• DoorDash order
This wa my first time ordering from here. I'm glad I didn't read prior reviews, or would have skipped. First,the Garden Side Salad was great. One of the best side salads I've had. It had the standard lettuce, tomatoes but also included a bit of purple cabbage, cheddar cheese, lots of cucumber with croutons. The house dressing was good.
For the Penne Diavolo , despite comments in other reviews, I found it had plenty of spinach, sun-dried tomatoes and was seasoned perfectly. Not bland. The red pepper spice came through which I loved. i love spicy foods. Pasta was cooked well. i did add grilled chicken which also added flavor. it was cooked and seasoned nicely as well.My only 2 minor critiques would be I would have like old bigger pieces of the sun-dried tomatoes vs their being cropped as small as they were. More of the creamy Alfredo sauce would have rounded out perfection. Overall, it was very good and I was not disappointed.
S
Sebastian C
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 10/6/25
• DoorDash order
Baked Mostaccioli and Chocolate Éclair Cake were both great!! The extra meatball is pretty big if you order it. Great portions for both.
B
Belinda R
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/21/25
• DoorDash order
We ordered two of the Penne Diavolo. The two entrees looked different from each other and tasted slightly different. One was white cream sauce, the other was pink and had hardly any spinach. Not sure what was going on but it was apparent the pink one had been not made the way it is usually made - we order this dish all the time from here
The white one tasted the same as when we'd ordered before. The pink one tasted a little different.
Both were supposed to be Penne Diavolo and should have looked and tasted the same.
That being said, all the food tasted good Just that one of the Penne Diavolo entrees we ordered was off. The kitchen should have thrown the one out and started over, so both orders were the same. Just bad service on Barnellis' part.
R
Ruth S
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/31/24
• DoorDash review
The pasta was overcooked (even for delivery) and was rather bland. I got the rigatoni with vodka sauce and the penne with spinich (not much that I could find) and sun dried tomatoes.
