Bartolo’s Sugar House, Salt Lake City, Utah, is the best Italian restaurant in Utah 2025. It's your neighborhood Italian restaurant, serving handcrafted, fresh pasta and bread prepared in-house every …
Everything was amazing!! The Smoked Salmon Benedict had incredible flavor, the Shrimp Spaghetti was delicious and cooked beautifully. The Blueberry Baby "Pan" Cake we got with chocolate chips instead of blueberries and my child loved it. I liked the SD Garlic Bread but wish it had a larger side of dipping sauce as it definitely wasn't enough for the 4 pieces. Lastly, I was really happy with the Small Fruit Bowl because it came with a great variety of apples, blueberries, strawberries, blackberries, and cantaloupe. I highly recommend the food!!
S
Stephanie V
4 contributions
Loved
• 6/15/26
• DoorDash order
Based on the photos and what you described, I’d absolutely give a 👍 to all of these:
✅ Chicken Parmigiana — The star of the meal. The cheese pull, the sauce, and the perfectly cooked pasta looked incredible. Restaurant-quality even after delivery.
✅ Rigatoni Bolognese — Rich, hearty meat sauce coating every piece of rigatoni. The pasta looked perfectly al dente and packed with flavor.
✅ Porchetta (Pork Belly) — Crispy, beautifully caramelized pork belly with a fresh salad. Looks expertly prepared with great texture contrast.
✅ Grilled Broccolini — Charred, vibrant, and generously topped with parmesan. Not an afterthought side dish at all.
✅ Grilled Garlic Bread — Golden, buttery, loaded with herbs and parmesan. This deserves its own fan club.
❓ Cheesecake in a Jar — Since it wasn’t pictured or mentioned, I’d only recommend it if you actually ordered and enjoyed it.
For the DoorDash ratings I’d do:
👍 Chicken Parmigiana
👍 Rigatoni Bolognese
👍 Porchetta - Pork Belly
👍 Grilled Broccolini
👍 Grilled Garlic Bread
👎 or Skip Cheesecake in a Jar (unless you ate it)
And for a shorter review on DoorDash:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely outstanding! Bartolo’s Sugar House delivered one of the best Italian meals we’ve had in Salt Lake City. The Chicken Parmigiana was phenomenal, the pasta was perfectly al dente, the Bolognese was rich and flavorful, and the garlic bread was incredible. Even the broccolini was cooked perfectly. Everything arrived hot, fresh, and beautifully packaged. You can tell they care about quality from the kitchen all the way through delivery. Authentic Italian flavors, generous portions, and flawless execution. We’ll definitely be ordering again! 🍝🇮🇹❤️
A
Autumn J
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/10/23
• DoorDash order
The food was mostly good. However, the portion size of the Seasonal Risotto was ridiculously small for the price. I replated onto a salad plate and it took up about 2/3 of the plate. The Kids Pasta didn't have much sauce and will be dry tomorrow when my niece decides to finish it. The Beet Tomato Burrata was the best value of the bunch.
E
Erica C
Local Expert • 76 contributions
Liked
• 2/22/26
• DoorDash order
The Butternut Risotto was inedible. I would never order this again. waaaay too much balsamic on top and the sun-dried tomatoes just weren't good in it
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo was delicious, as always.
Kids Pasta was a generous portion.
Cheesecake in a Jar was delicious.
Potato Wedges are always bangarang
J
JESSE P
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/23/22
• DoorDash order
The flavoring of our entrees were not good in my opinion. Maybe it was an off day for the cook(s)? The Rigatoni Bolognese was bland and my husband took one bite of the Bucatini All'Amatriciana and said is was gross. The prices are pretty high so unless you have eaten here before and like the food, I wouldn't recommend taking the chance.
On a side note, when we picked up our order I asked specifically about the espresso and was assured it was in the bag, only to get home and find it wasn't. The servers who helped me were not very friendly. All in all I would not recommend ordering from this restaurant.
