Benny's Pizza is a pizzeria run by a family in Spring Lake Heights, New Jersey. Benny's Pizza has been serving excellent pizzas and Italian cuisine to residents and guests of Spring Lake Heights, Spri…
Delicious cheesesteak!! There's actually a good amount of meat on it compared to other local
Places. Definitely recommend ordering one from bennys!!
S
Siobhan O
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/19/25
• DoorDash order
The pasta sauce they use/make was very sour so both the Chicken Parmigiana SubCheese Pizza were poor due to this. Also the Chicken Caesar Wrap had too much of anchovies taste which was unpleasant. The Mozzarella Sticks were very good but the marinara sauce like the others was sour so overall this was poor. They did pack the food well and the portions were normal.
M
Michelle N
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/16/23
• DoorDash order
The food sucked and I chose this place because of the great reviews! Chicken Parmigiana Sub might as well have been called a bread and cheese sandwich with sauce, the amount chicken was appauling! $8 for 3 tiny meatballs and the Italian Wedding Soup was also underwhelming, barely any flavor and they don't even use the little ball pasta :( the Penne Vodka was basically a pink butter sauce but again not enough flavor, overall everything was extremely bland and overpriced and im not 1 to leave reviews especially bad ones but for $70+ this place was a rip off to say the least!
C
Christine S
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Loved
• 4/18/25
• DoorDash order
I love this place, Benny's knows how to keep you coming back for more. there food is fresh, hot, and delicious always. when you eat in, they stuff you, they are such nice ppl, I can go on & on about how great they are.
E
Eileen M
1 contributions
Loved
• 4/29/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered a 2 liter bottle of Coke and received Diet. I normally wouldn't care but I have a medical condition that is triggered by the artificial sweetener in Diet. When I contacted Bennys they told me they were out of Coke and asked the driver to contact me with other options but that he responded with "No, it's ok" and grabbed the diet. Poor communication.
