Ordered the Little Italy Sub and Pullman Calzone, along with Statue Of Liberty Cheesesticks and a Brownie.
Not disappointed at all! The sub especially was among the best sandwiches I've ever eaten from a pizza restaurant. The calzone and cheese sticks were equally delicious, and I recommend an extra Marinara Cup for dipping!
The brownie was very rich and chocolatey. Crispy on the edges, gooey in the middle.
If you want to try a good pizza or a sandwich from someplace besides the usual chains, you can't go wrong here.
A
Amber Rose b
10 contributions
Liked
• 3/4/26
• DoorDash order
this pizza was honestly the best Pizza ive ever eaten! Sooo perfectly cooked, so cheesy, perfect amount of sauce, toppings etc. got a buffalo chicken pizza and it was DELICIOUS!! Cheese sticks were phenomenal. wings were great!Garlic Butter CupMarinara CupThe West Town Pizza (12")Hand Tossed Pizza (12")Bone in Buffalo NY WingsStatue Of Liberty Cheesesticks
C
Carolyn T
1 contributions
Loved
• 8/7/25
• DoorDash order
I had the cheese pizza at my grandson's birthday I was delighted to find one here Statue Of Liberty Cheesesticks were soo good the portion size was large.t was hot and fresh. I will definitely order again
B
Brittany Z
3 contributions
Liked
• 10/7/23
• DoorDash order
Normally I love BCP but tonight was a big city disappointment. We paid 23$ for a large pizza (just for the specialty pizza) that was room temp at best when it got here, as well as the macaroni bites, if they were straight out of the fryer they might have been good but they were mush really. Maybe poke some holes in the top of the packaging so condensation doesn't build up as much? Not meaning to be rude with that, just genuine assistance offered. This isn't the stores fault I know, which is why I'm giving a 4* but it's still kind of frustrating.
N
Nathan R
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/3/25
• DoorDash order
Pullman Calzone : I ordered breakfast sausage and mushrooms, and IF there were mushrooms, I couldn't taste them. Normally, a lot of sausage is a good thing. But this thing had so much it drowned out any mushrooms and felt like my 2 toppings were extra sausage.
Statue Of Liberty Cheesesticks: Honestly? They were just "okay" tonight. There were more air bubbles in the dough than cheese on them.
