since opening our doors in 2014, we strive to elevate local pizza we start with - handmade dough - our original sauce - the best ingredients we can find - fresh vegetables - high quality cheese we l…
Cheesesticks are the best in town. Freshly baked with delicious mozzarella cheese. Unfortunately twice we have ordered a llarge and received a small. Doordash compensated us immediately. Will definitely order again.
H
Heather H
17 contributions
Loved
• 1/15/26
• DoorDash order
Both pizzas are delicious, however the bourbon drizzle wasn't on the Tipsy Chicken. Will definitely order again! Both pizzas were cooked to perfection with an abundance of toppings and arrived piping hot!
A
Atonya M
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Loved
• 9/25/25
• DoorDash order
Holy cheese dream!! The Chicago Stuffed (12") was crazy delicious and so was the Navy Pier Garlic Knots!! Couldn't have been happier. The crust was great and not overdone. It was still hot when we got it so that just added to the bliss! We'll definitely be ordering this again. You rock Big City ;)
K
K B
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Liked
• 3/3/26
• DoorDash order
I can't believe that we haven't ordered from Big City Pizza before now! My bad! We ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch and it arrived hot and delicious! The crust on the hand tossed is perfect! It's soft and the bottom is crispy done! Great dough texture and flavor. The edge is great with a little real butter on it before going after the next slice. The small was perfect for us with a few slices left for a snack tomorrow.
The only downside is the Cheescake. Even though it's the great and famous Eli's, it is a prepackaged mini slice and not even 2" across at the widest point...and that just isn't worth the price charged. We were very disappointed. Heck, three bites and gone!
We will definitely be ordering more PIZZA from here in the future! :) :)
A
Alexander N
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/5/25
• DoorDash order
Big City Pizza used to be the best thing crust in town(3-4 years ago). Not sure what happened but they just stopped being great and are just average now. Good taste, but its like they purposely leave the outer inch ring of the pizza without toppings. So you basically getting a small pizza (with toppings) with a big outer crust. I was trying them again to see if they had changed and they havent (2 years later). I will go back to not using them. Damiano's is now the best thin crust in town. Im giving 2 stars bc it was still tasty, what little I had.
