After ovethinking about ordering this for weeks, I finally tried it. And wow! I was initially worried it wouldn't be enough to justify the price and a full lunch. But, the well-cooked potato was bigger than my hand, topped with a generous amount of smoky brisket and perfectly melted cheddar. I have previously ordered a meat plate twice and was underwhelmed. Turns out I was ordering the wrong item. Now that I know about the #2 most ordered gem, I will definitely be ordering The Botato from now on. Possibly...a chopped brisket sandwich will be my next attempt.
S
sarah l
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Loved
• 7/3/26
• DoorDash order
Was pleasantly surprised, considering the driver had one stop before delivering my food. The red beans and rice were insanely amazing with a good little kick to them afterwards. The potato had a ton of cheese on top so for people who don't like a lot of cheese to the point it literally acts as a thick blanket over the meat. Both were amazing very impressed.
R
Rona E
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/4/25
• DoorDash order
The potato salad was disgusting and it was a very small portion. The chopped beef sandwich did not have any taste to it. They also forgot to include the beef tips that we ordered. The red beans & rice was a very small portion as well; the size you would feed a child with not an adult. I will not be eating here ever again.
B
Brooke M
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/13/24
• DoorDash order
This was not a The Pitmaster's Burger this was a soybean patty that tasted 2 days old. I called to let the owner know and sent and email and was never called back nor emailed back. The quality of the $20 burger was unacceptable. I wouldn't even rate it a one. Very disappointed! I will not go back. Nothing on the burger was good quality.
A
April B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/7/25
• DoorDash review
The food was great but it wansnt enough for the price of the food I had the beef tips which were very good and the greens beans were deliI and i had to order sepbut the price did not match the quality !!
