We're two working-class guys who have spent our entire lives in this restaurant. We've worked in every aspect of the restaurant business, from dishwashing to executive management. We both had a dream …
One of the best local owned burger places on the Island! Kinda wish there was more cheese on the Cheese Fries, but I guess that could've made them soggy. My Cheeseburger was fantastic, 5 Piece Chicken Nuggets tasted real good & they were so crunchy! Milkshakes are on point too. I was going to take pics but I couldn't help myself, too busy digging in..
D
David J
Local Expert • 30 contributions
Loved
• 6/30/25
• DoorDash order
The Chipotle Black Bean Burger (Vegetarian) was incredibly flavorful. I didnt miss it being beef at all very satisfying.. The Onion Rings were extremely crunchy and delicious!! Boxcar Burgers have not ever let me down.. Incredibly flavorful food and out standing prices!!
K
Kaela B
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 4/24/26
• DoorDash order
We LOVE boxcar burger. One of the best burger spots and my favorite Onion Rings ever. The chicken sandwich also is really good from here if you're not a burger person. They also have the best pickles they're tiny diced and perfect for your sandwich I even get extra on the side. The portions are perfect, food is always fresh and we will always come back !
J
James B
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 1/8/26
• DoorDash order
Best burger joint on Long Island. Double Cheeseburger is amazing.10 Piece Chicken Nuggets are some of the best nuggets I've ever had. Portion sizes are as expected. Every thing is made fresh and I will order again!
A
Ashley T
1 contributions
Loved
• 5/4/26
• DoorDash order
The customer service was wonderful and the burgers and fries were fresh and delicious. Portion size was not too much, but not too little. It was perfect and satisfying. I would order again.
