Unfortunately it was not that great. I ordered a half dozen bagels and they were cut very lopsided, so much so i couldn't get the one half in the toaster. They also were not that fresh, and they seemed smaller from what i remember. It was nothing special. I had a muffin and that was very good. Disappointing to say the least. My first time ordering from here since they came to Buffalo.
A
Austin A
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/20/26
• DoorDash order
Let me start by saying my breakfast sandwich was good. The everything bagel was decent, (but bagel jays were much much better). I also ordered a jalapeño cheddar bagel and a French toast, both with cream cheese. These were not bagels. They were thin, dense, no hole in the middle. They were essentially doughy rolls. Definitely not light, crisp or crunchy with a springy inside, like a bagel should be. For a place that's supposed to specialize in bagels, they were extremely mid. Please bring back bagel jays!
N
Nicole P
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
I got the Egg, Peppered Bacon & Cheese on a sesame seed bagel but there were Sooo many seeds on the bagel that it made the whole sandwich very unpleasant and I ended up throwing it out. The Twice Baked Hashbrown was a bit dry and flavor not my liking so I threw that out too. The coffee was ok.
C
Cherie H
14 contributions
Loved
• 6/26/26
• DoorDash order
NEW! Vanilla Iced Coffee was amazing! Sriracha Honey Sunrise ....omg. delicious! hot, fresh and perfect.
S
Stephen T
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/3/26
• DoorDash order
Bagels look and smell great. Breakfast sandwiches are decent but pricey. Cheesy Hash Brown Muffins could use some crunch. Paid for but did not receive any cream cheese. Thats frustrating when that cost inflates the fees, taxes, and tip and then you dont even get the thing you bought. Thumbs down for that. Not super impressed with my first visit but willing to try again.
