As close as it gets to Massapequa's All American. Elite burgers at an affordable rate. Milkshakes are next level, and the Quarterpounder w/ Cheese is the perfect burger.
A
Anthony P
Local Expert • 17 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/1/25
• DoorDash order
I had the chance to try out Burger City tonight after seeing quite a few online reviews, which seemed to build up some hype.
The burger itself was definitely the highlight of the meal. It was nicely packaged in a warm wrapping and arrived at the perfect temperature – warm and delicious! It was seasoned just right and wonderfully juicy.
The onion rings were crispy and thin, and they tasted like they might be homemade. Unfortunately, they arrived cold.
The French fries were also crispy, but seemed like a fairly standard type. They also arrived cold.
The strawberry milkshake was a bit of a disappointment. It tasted like a vanilla milkshake with strawberry syrup added, which wasn't really what I was hoping for.
Lastly, the side order of pickles was quite surprising. Paying a premium price for just three slices felt like a bit of a joke.
Overall, the burger was great, but some of the other items didn't quite live up to expectations.
D
Debra N
Local Expert • 71 contributions
Loved
• 3/29/26
• DoorDash order
Love the choices to make your burger your own. There was a choice for no salt which I like. Love the Sweet Potato Tots no sugar and well done. Burger City never disappoints. Hot dogs are better than Nathans
J
Jonathan H
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
I had seen an article about a Shake Shack coming to LI and that it would be close to Burger City. I had never had it before so I decided to get it to secure my support vs the new guy.... I was a bit disappointed. The burger is basic. nothing spectacular. The taste was bland and I really wanted it to be amazing.... it's unfortunate.
The fries were familiar.... they are those coated fries that you can buy from restaurant depot.... smh.
A
Ashley G
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Loved
• 8/30/25
• DoorDash order
Slamming as always! Burgers are a little smaller in size compared to 5 guys but taste way better! Everything tastes brand new! This is me and my husband's go to order!
