To you and yours, from our family to yours
Try the best pizzas in Chesterfield to find a new favorite.
Original Buscemi's has become one of the most popular restaurants in the neighborhood thanks to …
Buscemis food is amazing! The sauce is sweet but not tooo sweet. Calzones were SO good. Italian sausage, olives, and provolone cheese...melted in my mouth! Tha k you, Buscemis!!
C
Cherie B
Local Expert • 355 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/9/25
• DoorDash order
This is really bad... Sadly I I'd give this 0 stars if I could... They are selling reheated single square slices sitting there to be sold individually as small and medium fresh pizzas! They throw 6 slices together and throw extra cheese on top of the cheese and pepperoni already on it and throw it in the oven again...It comes out so hard around the edges of slices that shouldn't be hard because the are supposed to be in the middle and the edge crust on a couple slices is so Rock hard you can't even eat it... The sauce is really dark and tasted weird...I decided to call and speak with the manager and he was arguing with me and lying about it... I told him I worked at a Buscemis and I know what he's doing. So I will be taking my business to a Buscemis that doesn't sell reheated square pizzas. I do not recommend this Buscemis.
S
Shannon E
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/21/25
• DoorDash order
The meatball Roll had a whole 4 small meatballs in it and was very doughy, the Large Cheese Stick were flat and seemed like it did not have enough time for the dough to rise.... very disappointed
C
Cherie B
Local Expert • 355 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/18/24
• DoorDash review
Pizza is usually awesome. Today it wasnt. Looks like it was sitting around too long and they threw a ton of oregano and cheese on top of it... Usually Pepperoni is on top they were buried and it was so spicy our mouths were burning.. Its usually sweet... Usually it's very thick and it was thin and chewy. Disappointing.
C
Cherie B
Local Expert • 355 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/31/24
• DoorDash order
6 Piece Square Cheese Pizza was ok.. It looks good! But it tasted weird... Tasted like a a gas stove and pineapple was sour and pepperoni has that weird gas stove taste to it.
