I actually order the eggplant hot sub. It was great!!!!!! Calabresellas is a jewel here in Rochester. Real Italian.
S
Stephanie D
Emerging Expert • 109 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/23/26
• DoorDash order
Sloppy, hard bread, salty ham, too many onions, little to no lettuce or sliced tomatoes. Toasted bread and I did not ask for that. The cheese was mended on the ham. It barely had any flavor at all. It was one of the worst subs ever.
L
Laura K
5 contributions
Loved
• 9/2/25
• DoorDash order
I paid an extra .50 cents for extra tomatoes, and another extra.50 cents for extra mayonnaise. I received neither. That said, their product is amazing. The bread is delicious and the pasta salad had so much flavor. My advice would be choose pick up rather than delivery to make sure your order was made correctly. Other than not getting the extras that I paid for; the quality of food is superb.
C
Chloe G
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/13/26
• DoorDash order
The Mac Salad has no flavor or seasoning, and is just swimming in mayonnaise, beyond just bad, utterly disgusting. the Shaved Steak Hot Sub was also a major disappointment, though the steak has the feel of high quality it is not seasoned at all. The bread is soggy so what you are left with is just this we flavorless mush. YUCK! it's incredible the charge so much for sub-mediocre food. ended up throwing it out because it was completely inedible. save your money!
C
Charmain B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/19/26
• DoorDash order
I order a large tuna paid for extra mayo no mayo was on either side of bread no oil. The bread is to hard and all the tuna was on the paper due to all the toppings was at the bottom and tuna on top not inside of the bread it was made like an open face sandwich. Never had this issue at the other location.
