Captain Cookie and the Milkman offers freshly baked cookies, dairy from local creameries, and custom ice cream sandwiches.
Kirk made his first cookie when he was four years old and has been enamored …
In my opionion, this is hands down the best cookie establishment to ever exist. Crumbl & Insomnia stand in the shadow of this giant when it comes to flavor, quality and consistency. Ive been ordering here for years, and I haven't been disappointed a single time.
N
Nyx M
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/28/25
• DoorDash order
The prices do not match port sizes at all especially icecream, prob would not order from this place again due to high prices and low portion sizes, ive tried both ice cream and cookies and the taste of both is equal to that I can obtain at a Walmart
H
Hannah M
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/23/24
• DoorDash order
The cookies were good I guess. The cookie dough tasted like playdoh so I was pretty disappointed about that. I tried my friend's cupcake milkshake and it tasted more like yogurt than a milkshake. Overall I'm pretty disappointed with this place and probably won't order from here again.
E
Erin D
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Liked
• 8/23/25
• DoorDash review
Yummy cookies! We tried the chocolate chip, double chocolate, snickerdoodle, confetti, peanut butter, and daily special. The cookies were super fresh, and were just the right amount of soft without being crumbly. They weren't super huge considering the cost, but they were good; we would order them again!