Captain Cookie and The Milkman
4.6(200+)•
Bakery•
Store Info•
Temporarily closed
Order for later
4.6(200+)•
$$•Bakery
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Assorted Bakers Dozen
$39.00
•90% (11)
#2 Most liked
Double Chocolate
$3.90
The Duo
$7.80
Chocolate Chip
$3.90
Assorted Half Dozen
$19.50
•74% (31)
#1 Most liked
Ice Cream Sandwich
$10.20
•88% (9)
#3 Most liked
Reviews200+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
M
Matthew J
2 contributionsLoved
• 3/6/23Pretty good cookies! Not overly sweet sugar bombs like has become common elsewhere. Definitely good candidates for dipping and with ice cream.
A
Amanda K
4 contributionsLiked
• 11/2/23Great cookies but they can be hit or miss - sometimes they are moist and delicious and othertimes they are dry. Suggest ordering midday.
J
Joy R
Emerging Expert • 112 contributionsDidn't like
• 3/7/23So the 2% milk I ordered with the 2 Cookies & Milk wasn't available, and without asking me, I was substituted soy milk. And charged for it. I don't drink soy milk, and it'll just go bad in my refrigerator, which is a waste.
This is the second time I've ordered 2 Cookies & Milk and both times the milk I requested was not the milk I received. Considering I only really want the cookies, I'll just bake some myself, rather than try this place again. Too bad, because the cookies themselves are really good, but not worth the hassle and extra charge.
T
Tashi S
4 contributionsLoved
• 6/9/24Thank you guys for being so dope for my son's Birthday! Ice cream cookie sandwiches are the bomb. Just do it
J
Joy R
Emerging Expert • 112 contributionsLoved
• 6/29/25I love Captain Cookie and the Milkman, and the Chocolate Chip cookies are the best!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store