Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium welcomes you!
We hope you have a great time at Captain Tony's.
Thank you for visiting, and please tell your friends!
Since 1972, Captain Tony's Rochester, NY res…
Outstanding calzone super fresh dough and the fillings were plentiful and delicious
J
Jhalysa J
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/22/25
• DoorDash order
For an extra $4 for meatballs I expected more than one meatball... sauce is bland too. My kid approves but not sure I'll be ordering again.
P
Patty P
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/13/26
• DoorDash review
I didn't want to leave a review but the last order I made I was not happy about it.
I normally get a large pepperoni pizza and a calzone.
The pizza was very bland tasting and the calzone was terrible. I had ordered it with provolone cheese, ricotta cheese, onions and mushrooms.
Whoever made it didn't cook the onions, spinach whatever kind of onions they used took over the entire calzone and it and ruined it. I normally don't complain but paying almost $60 for the order I had to. The calzone was inedible bc of the raw onion flavor not to mention that they were not cooked and chunky! I never had a problem with your store but I did now. I wanted to make you aware of the taste of the food that I ordered. Hopefully I was the only one that day that received their order that was inedible.
D
Danielle B
7 contributions
Loved
• 10/11/25
• DoorDash order
split in half is perfect for two kids who love chicken sandwiches my dinner planning really easy on a Friday! They follow directions in the special instructions the way I needed them to so that my kids would eat it and I am grateful for that. A lot of places miss the special instructions or don't allow them. I took a bite myself. It was still warm. That was nice and toasty and just the way I needed it to be for them. Thank you again.
A
Aaliyah T
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Loved
• 7/6/25
• DoorDash order
By far the best Calzone I've ever had. The Calzone was huge! Can definitely split it between two people! Definitely will order again.
