I was semi-expecting the Red Pizza (6 Cut Pizza) to taste like the red pizza from Colarusso's Café in Avoca (or how it used to taste before management changed). However, the red pizza from Colarusso's Dunmore had its' own flavor, which I liked. I will definitely be ordering it again.
The 1 pound wing bites w/ blue cheese & celery was also really good!!
The only issue I had was that they came with the incorrect wing sauce. I had ordered "hot" wing sauce, but received a "hot garlic" wing sauce.
This was my first time trying this restaurant, so I wanted to try the "hot" wing bites before trying other flavors.
However, the incorrect wing sauce that I received with my order was very good and flavorful, and I would definitely get it again!! The wing bites were also very saucy, which I absolutely loved as too many restaurants in the area don't give nearly enough wing sauce with their bites and wings.
The portion was generous as well. I think that they definitely gave more than one pound of wing bites which is ok with me. Ha ha
E
Elizabeth C
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/1/26
• DoorDash order
WOpen White Pizza (12 Cut Pizza)Red Pizza (12 Cut Pizza) w meatball. Wouldn't order again. Both trays really lacked cheese and were dry, especially the white. Wing bites chewy and no celery. Order certainly not worth$73!!!
R
Rob K
50 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/12/25
• DoorDash order
The Red Pizza (12 Cut Pizza)was very greasy and as usual, the quality was inconsistent. This restaurant NEVER has consistent quality. The dough was stale and definitely NOT WORTH THE MONEY!
C
Cody C
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/19/25
• DoorDash order
The Fresh Tomato Pizza (6 Cut Pizza) was absolutely incredible. Perfectly seasoned and not as greasy as I expected. Well sized sliced. The French Fries with Cheese were also great. Definitely ordering this again.
L
Laura M
Emerging Expert • 44 contributions
Liked
• 3/27/26
• DoorDash order
hands down best red pizza. Sauce is amazing, friendly staff, and great value! Red Pizza (12 Cut Pizza)
