The Tulsa World building in downtown Tulsa, Oklahoma, hosted the first Coney Island Hot Weiners in 1926. Years ago, Christ Economou arrived in the United States from Greece via Ellis Island. He follow…
My Coney Islander days go back to the 60s, when I was in Jr High and looking to buy a snack before my mom picked me up from HM (someone at this store will know school what I'm referring to! My family has patronized them for YEARS - I regret I can't get to the store much, physically, anymore, but can't go without my coney fix in any case. The store is always what it's been: clean, bright, the staff are delightful, and the coneys are the best in town, in my opinion and I've been to every coney place there is here!
S D
Emerging Expert • 47 contributions
Loved
• 6/6/25
• DoorDash order
The coneys are really good here and the prices are cheap, Would definitely recommend it if you're wanting a good Coney!
L
Larry L
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/16/25
• DoorDash order
this store is usually great, but today the coneys I received were awful. the hot dogs wre tough and chewy and the buns were stale and hard. very disappointed.
C
Channing J
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/24/24
• DoorDash review
Sooo..... I thought I was ordering coney islander. First bite Iwas not happy. I think I got the weenie that had been there since they opened that morning. And, I think i got the last bowl of chili only because they were able to scrape out enough to fill up a bowl. Everything (one coney and bowl of chili) tasted burnt and/or near its "do not consume" date. Everyone has bad days, maybe I caught them on theirs. I will give them benefit of the doubt. First experience was NOT good.
L
La'Metra C
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/21/24
• DoorDash review
I got chili cheese coneys with mustard and onion. The chilli has no flavor, the wiener was hard, and the onions are old! will never order from here again. The best one is in owasso
