Cookie Society was born from the shared passion of Marissa and Jeff Allen, a husband-and-wife team. Marissa, a lifelong baking enthusiast, was inspired by a famous NYC bakery known for its incredible …
SERIOUSLY AMAZING!! From care of packaging, presentation and pure deliciousness, Cookie So iety exceeded all expectation. The Oatmeal Cream Pie is now my all-time favorite cookie. It looked fantastic and tasted even better. The Brownie came cradled in a wrapper like that of a cupcake. It was moist, chocolatey and the perfect proportion. You can bet I will be ordering more of these decadent treats in the near future.
W
Wendy A
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Loved
• 11/14/25
• DoorDash order
Will definitely be ordering Cookie Society again when the sweet craving strikes! The Four Big Cookies are packed full of flavor. Very few places do a snickerdoodle right. You can actually taste the spices, and not overly sweet. Perfection. Surprised how good the glazed oatmeal was - ordered from other reviews, not normally an oatmeal cookie fan but they were spot on. It is delicious. Will be getting it again! Everything was baked perfectly. Not over or underdone. All good warmed in the microwave for a few seconds. Great place!
M
Michelle A
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/25/25
• DoorDash order
Undercooked sugar cookies with minimal/inconsistent mix-ins. Chocolate chip is an up charge yet had just a few pieces.
Because they are undercooked, they are not to be reheated in the microwave (doesn't matter the setting) and can only be eaten at room temperature.
I will try them again, maybe a different location and different flavors. I do believe they are freshly baked and the packaging was well sealed for protection.
I had chocolate chip and sweet potato.
T
TANIKA R
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 11/4/25
• DoorDash order
Some cookie companies just make big cookies but these cookies are crafted from love. The croissant cookie is amazing not sure how they did it but they DID THAT. The iced oatmeal is Devine. The chocolate chip is best warmed and the sweet potato cookie cake is great. They are always fresh and I would definitely order over and over. Sorry I forget to take pics because I always dive in...
T
Torrie H
3 contributions
Liked
• 3/14/26
• DoorDash order
Tried a new flavored cookie (French toast) it's sooo good. The banana pudding will always be my favorite. Super soft & always the same size everytime.
