oh they like it cheesy alright
the Garlic Cheesy Bread with Marinara Sauce (8) was actually pretty good. could have used some more seasoning though.. all the extra cheese they put in it almost sucks the seasoning right up
14" Large Donair Pizza was nice I asked for it well done and they cooked it a little longer. definitely followed direction
K
Katerina W
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/5/26
• DoorDash review
Just a heads-up for anyone considering ordering from 127th St Cosmic Pizza & Donair.
Based on my experience, I would not recommend them. The pizzas we ordered were extremely soggy and tasted off. I returned to the restaurant with the pizzas to explain the issue, but my concerns were dismissed, and they refused to provide a refund.
I know everyone works hard for their money, so I wanted to share my experience to help others make an informed decision.
We will not be ordering from here again.
The restaurant itself was also very dirty and unkept when we arrived to pick up.
A
Amanda W
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/11/26
• DoorDash order
The Donair Pizza is good, but we thought we should try the 16" X-Large Greek Pizza. The photos advertise it as a pizza with fresh toppings, but they put the cheese on top and baked it so it became mushy and floppy. It was also undercooked. I ordered a Brooklyn style crust, but it couldn't have been one. The pieces were small and the dough was thick. Sad to say that Greek Pizza was pretty darn gross.
S
Sarah P
38 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/13/23
• DoorDash order
The Medium Beef Donair didn't have enough sauce, the Dipping Sauce side was super tiny and the 12" Medium Donair Pizza crust (hand tossed) was really dry. Donair meat was ok but everything is generally overpriced.
R
Rowen T
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/13/25
• DoorDash review
Do yourself a favor and don't order from here. Tastes like red swan pizza but more expensive. Some bits felt like there was I kid you not sand grit in my teeth. Bland, cheese was slimey and mushy. Save your money and spend it literally anywhere else. Would never order again, and don't recommend anyone to order either. You're lighting your money on fire with this one, don't let the reviews fake you out like they did with me.
Doesn't have tamper proof packaging either, you're at a risk there alone.
Pizza looked and tasted like it was sitting for a few hours before it got delivered to us. You're better off getting a 7elven pizza than this abomination. 3 of us had a slice and we threw the rest out.
