Coterie Pizza
Coterie means a gathering of people with common tastes. Pizza is a food to share…
Coterie Pizza utilizes a master crafted Italian stone oven and pizzas that try to match. We try to be …
The pizzas had a great flavor and the crust was amazing! However, more toppings on the pizzas would have been nice, especially on the Chicken Bruschetta which was lacking on the chicken.
T
T. F
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 6/10/26
• DoorDash order
the best pizza not only in the DeKalb area, the ENTIRE northern Indiana area. This is legitimate fire cooked, fresh ingredients and wonderfully priced. 2 chain pizzas is literally more expensive than 3 award winning pies from here. A can't miss. The beer Beer Cheese & Bacon and Beer Cheese app are bangers. Love the hot Hot Honey and BBQ burnt ends pies. Great local staff too. Tip them if you get take out. They earn it.
S
Seth M
11 contributions
Loved
• 8/8/25
• DoorDash order
pretty good 👍 definitely a different and alternative style of pizza compared to what most of us around here are used to but that dough is definitely soft, fluffy, and sweet. very nice. very natural tasting flavorful food. I'll have to try it in the restaurant sometime instead of DoorDash,I'm sure it'll be even better. You should advertise and serve this pizza at the local fair coming up. I would give out some small free samples for people if I were you. Give em a little taste 😋
K
Kimberly H
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/14/23
• DoorDash order
We ordered the Artichoke and Spinach Pizza that also came with Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheeses. Pizza was exceptional and staff was helpful in describing pizzas, rolls and sandwiches. DoorDash is only delivery option. Pizza was cold and we are only minutes away. Driver for DoorDash was friendly and professional but had no type of warming equipment available to her or used with the Pizza Delivery.
R
Rachel B
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/18/23
• DoorDash order
Great pizza and cheese bread!!! They have more options on the restaurant menu that I wish was available on Doorsash because they are amazing. We dined in and had a bruschetta pizza and some kind of cheesy pasta and they were both fantastic! The beer wall was fun too! This place is a must try!
