Our pizza was delicious, just the right amount of toppings and sauce. The wings were crunchy AND juicy. I appreciate they gave us a selection of sauces and did not charge extra. The Cottage Inn quickly went to one of our favorites, we can't wait to try the rest of the menu!
N
Natalie M
8 contributions
Loved
• 5/25/26
• DoorDash order
a place with a really well crafted pizza. Toppings were delicious, the crust was perfection and I liked the ways to personalize the pizzas. Bravo!
K
Kelsey B
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/23/26
• DoorDash order
This may be a preference thing, but I was really disappointed in my order last night. I took a chance on Cottage Inn because I had heard good things, but it did not seem as fresh as I was expecting. Food was hot and well made, but the flavor was a mix between Little Caesars and Jets (two places I do not prefer). The pizza sauce and pineapple on my pizza did not have a lot of flavor and were not as rich as I was hoping. Cheese was melty, but almost in that sort of plastic-y way? Breadsticks were fine but the cheese on top tasted really artificial, as did the garlic drizzle that was on top. Portions were great though. It's possible I just didn't have appropriate expectations, but my order was around $25 for a medium pizza and breadstick—something I could have got for the same price at an independent shop with fresh ingredients. I will not order again. This might be the perfect place for you, but it was not my dream. Ranch was yummy!
K
Kyle H
7 contributions
Loved
• 11/5/25
• DoorDash order
I thought I got cheese bread but after inspection it's pizza just cut oddly like cheese bread. I feel bad now for and apologize, fantastic food. Oven Roasted InnWings were perfect and Build Your Own Pizza was cut different but great
E
Ella M
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/12/26
• DoorDash order
My BLT pizza didn't contain all of the ingredients. It was supposed to contain other than that the freshness amongst the pizza it wasn't cooked all the way, but the portion was accurate. The taste was decent and I don't think I would order from here again. And the breadsticks were super dry and didn't really carry much flavor. I accidentally ordered from a different cottage in location than what I normally do and was very disappointed by the quality.
