The 12-Pack Mini Is Dangerous (In the Best Way)
I grabbed the 12-pack of minis thinking, “Oh, these are small. I’ll just sample a few.”
That was a lie.
The minis are the perfect size — big enough to actually experience the flavor, small enough that you justify eating four without guilt. The texture? Soft center, slightly crisp edge, thick frosting that doesn’t feel cheap or overly sugary.
What surprised me most is that the minis aren’t just “cut-down versions.” They still hit with the same bold flavor punch as the full-size cookies. Each one feels intentional.
Pro move: the variety box makes it feel like a tasting flight. Great for sharing… or pretending you’re sharing.
Only downside? They disappear fast.
Would I buy again? Absolutely.
Would I buy the 12-pack thinking I have self-control? Also yes.
Will I actually show self-control? Unclear.
M
Mariah S
2 contributions
Loved
• 8/20/24
• DoorDash review
I'm so addicted to these cookies who knew I'd be happy to spend 40 bucks on 6 cookies but i just love them.
J
Julia M
2 contributions
Liked
• 9/24/25
• DoorDash order
The chocolate peanut butter cookie is good. It's really good. The snickerdoodle cookie is pretty snickerdoodle is good. The salted caramel chocolate, one that one's overrated or maybe there was too much sugar in the cookie bar because it just tasted a little off. Maybe the dough was not good this day. OK the Oreo cake one that one was really good. The chocolate chip cookie that was delicious and then the cake the real cake cookie cake that was super delicious scrumptious so good delicious yesyes
A
Allison T
Local Expert • 28 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/22/23
• DoorDash order
Missing toppings on two cookies, Oreo and raspberry donut. Not really an Oreo cookie without crème and rasp donut cookie with no raspberries... pretty lame when you spend a ton of money for gourmet cookies.
A
Amy C
Local Expert • 100 contributions
Liked
• 7/25/23
• DoorDash order
I really liked the Lemon Cupcake! There was too much frosting for me so I did scrape most of it off, but I did like the little white sprinkles and the flavor was really good! I also really liked the Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream. I love the chocolate Oreo cookie flavor, although I think I would prefer just some peanut butter swirled in or a light layer of peanut butter frosted on top as opposed to the peanut butter chips.
