Love the Cerulean Sugar Cookie. Color is so pretty and the icing and cookie is perfection. High expectations for consistency bc it's my favorite. Kentucky Butter Cake cookie was very good, too. Super grateful for the freshness and attractive cookies bc night time order. Pleased they weren't dry day old. Pricey! A luxury both $$$ and calories. Great order. Will order again.
R
Raine F
Local Expert • 22 contributions
Loved
• 4/28/22
• DoorDash order
best cookies. other cookie delivery places send them underbaked so they will be gooey but crumble sends then cooked through through warm. their best cookies are the ones with cream! (so far, berries and cream and Boston cream pie) we get them every week now!
C
Cynthia G
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/16/25
• DoorDash review
The strawberry skillet cookie was greasy and ugly as you can see in the picture. Also, the chocolate chip cookies did not look fresh. They looked flat and you could hardly see any chocolate chips so I'm disappointed and won't be ordering from that store again again on Brody Street.
S
Scarlett O B
1 contributions
Liked
• 1/31/26
• DoorDash order
Super good! Although there was one ores cookie that was signifigantly smaller than the other ones and the icing was super sloppy and was nowhere near the picture. The strawberry ones were good though! Would order again just in person.
N
Nick J
16 contributions
Loved
• 8/7/22
• DoorDash order
Seriously the best cookies. Banana bread might be my all time favorite but every week there's multiple flavors that undeniably slam. They also keep for a couple days in the fridge extremely well. 6 stars!
