We love this local spot! Da Matteos has fantastic service and the food is pretty quick even in large orders. We also highly recommend the Chicken Parm, and any of the gnocchi dishes.
A
Ali E
8 contributions
Loved
• 12/13/25
• DoorDash order
This is probably the best local pizza I've had since HelenBack was here. The Cheese Pizza for Kids is a perfect portion for 1 hungry person! The Fettuccine Alfredo for Kids wasn't as fresh as i expected. Noodles were a little hard & it missed the mark on flavor. I wish the Nutella Calzone was more evenly proportioned but it was definitley so good & worth trying! I'd order it again! Flavor was there, even in the dough- it was still fresh upon delivery.
B
Brent B
9 contributions
Loved
• 9/21/25
• DoorDash order
I rarely write reviews.
We live in Navarre...moved here about 2.5 years ago. We've tried every pizza joint and Da Matteo's is hands down the best and most consistent in this area. I've never been disappointed by their pizza.
My go to is a half pep, sausage and jalapeño with red sauce and a half white Piemontese (sp? One of their specialty white pizzas with sausage and mushrooms). So good.
Tonight, I also ordered, for the first time, a gluten-free (cauliflower crust) with sausage and jalapeños for my wife...she loved it. We also both loved the fried burrata.
Support this local restaurant because their food is awesome and very consistent. Buon Appetito!!!
K
Kimberly C
Local Expert • 38 contributions
Liked
• 10/18/25
• DoorDash order
Limoncello Cake was DELIGHTFUl!! Creamy and delicious but I'd prefer if it were more lemony.👍🏻 Would order again.Da’ Matteo Fríes were basic fries you could make at home from a bag of frozen French Fries so NOT WORTH THE COST. Mine arrived cold and had the described toppings scattered about with nothing to make them stick together.......MEH, Would not order again.
R
Rachel L
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/16/26
• DoorDash order
The grilled chicken that came with the fettuccine was completely dried out and tasted like cardboard. The focaccia bread tasted like naan bread with garlic on it. Was very disappointed in the quality of the food
