This is the best pizza you can get in Ohio. My family has gone here for years now, and no other pizza place comes close. Highly recommend the meatball pizza or any pizza with fresh mozzarella.
H
Holly K
3 contributions
Loved
• 5/17/26
• DoorDash order
Deweys and the Cheesecake Girl were absolutely delicious. Love that we can get half and half specialty pizzas, so we can always get half Green Lantern and try something new. The cheesecake had excellent flavor and density. Everything tasted fresh and it is also great the day after. Deweys is worth every penny, the quality is consistent, and they never disappoint.
J
Jennifer L
42 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/21/26
• DoorDash order
13 13" Pepperoni was a huge disappointment. No flavor, barely any pepperoni or cheese. Crust wasn't even flavorful. :( NOT, NOT worth $25.
R
Ron S
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/6/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza tasted OK, but the corporate cost cutting team has reduced the amount of added ingredients to absurd levels. Also they had the brilliant idea of upping the seasoning of some of the drastically reduced quantities of ingredients hoping no one would notice. We did. My wife is guessing they added a lot of white pepper.
Tiny sprinkles of smoked cheddar cheese, minute quantities of shredded chicken instead of actual pieces of buffalo chicken. Meatballs sliced into 4 to 6 pieces. Still looking for the bacon bits, roasted peppers and carmelized onions. Over the last few orders, it seems like the more added ingredients you order, the less of each ingredient is actually added to the pizza. Each added ingredient costs $3.99 and actual amounts, if they are there are worth no more than 50 cents.
We understand food prices have gone up, but messing with the quality of your product like this to cover up increasing your profits, that's brand burning to turn a quick profit.
This is a highly negative review because we really liked Dewey's Pizza. It is terrible watching another company trade their reputation for a quick buck.
C
Charles F
1 contributions
Loved
• 5/24/26
• DoorDash order
The 17" White pizza was delicious and the Side Candied Walnut & Grape was refreshing and was more than enough for two people to split as a side with as much pizza as we received. Would absolutely get again!
