We've returned to Barnegat with a classic menu of Italian delicacies, exquisite steaks, fresh seafood, and AMAZING thin crust brick oven pizza, based on our 20+ years of experience.
Matthew has succes…
Ordered a large thin crust with onions on whole pie and split meatballs and sausage on each side. First time getting the thin crust and I will say it was delicious! Same great flavor as a regular hand tossed pie version but light, crispy and less heavy as a regular pie. Sweetness of the onion mixed with the saltiness of the sausage and meatball jive really well. Overall would recommend and will be ordering again!
K
Kayla A
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/5/26
• DoorDash order
all food was terrible. Calamari wasn't cooked, frozen pizza basically, and the mussels were not rinsed properly. Muscles were hard to chew. the salad is $8 for a couple leafs of lettuce and 2 bread crumbs. If you're thinking of trying somewhere new don't because it's so bad they must know and not care if you order again. Don't waste your time
M
Matt L
Emerging Expert • 39 contributions
Loved
• 7/19/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza from here is legit and more importantly consistent! Always fresh ingredients and the crust always holds up to the toppings. And the meatballs are out of this world! Thinking of ordering them as a side next time!
D
Daria M
15 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/26/26
• DoorDash review
Well in the chicken parm dinner , the soup is soooo small but mostly it was the chicken parm . It was really difficult to cut and definitely not white meat ! It was thin and brown inside not soft white meat so it grossed me out ! The penne vodka was decent though.
C
Catherine A
Local Expert • 42 contributions
Loved
• 11/6/25
• DoorDash order
This East Bay Cheesesteak was a 20%-off special, so I tried it, and glad I did. The sesame sub roll was filled with tender beef, provolone, and the optional onions and peppers. Steak fries on the side were good, but the sandwich was delicious!
