Proper Sandwiches
East Hampton Sandwich Company unlocked its shop in 2012, later founder Hunter Pond earned welcome inclination for tasty, absolutely-willing grinders outweighed welcome obligation to …
Delicious sandwich that had plenty of goodies (meat/veggies) and a delicious bread that doesn't overwhelm the sandwich. Just the right amount. Not too thick but substantial enough to keep it together. ) The ingredients were so fresh and their fresh made chips were so worth the calories!
R
Ryanne V
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/2/26
• DoorDash order
Fries were the soggiest they've ever been. The bacon on the sandwich was really gross and not crispy at all and the sandwich was dry. Barely any turkey on it either. Not worth the price
S
Shan R
Local Expert • 23 contributions
Loved
• 5/3/25
• DoorDash order
This is my first time ordering from here but definitely won't be the last. It is delicious- the Salad of the Month was spot on (I would just add more shrimp in the future). All ingredients are fresh, right down to the corn cut off the cob. The Green Goddess is very flavorful. The sea salt fries are just meh 😕 but I can overlook it because everything else is spot on!
K
Khalil H
Local Expert • 98 contributions
Liked
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
The Classic was ok I got roast beef that was the best part there was way too much lettuce for the beef it wasn't a beef to lettuce ratio more like layers of lettuce. I was expecting a homemade tea not a bottle for almost $4 . It was fresh and tge beef was good but maybe on a bread next time. I would order again if I was choosing bread
C
Chance A
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/28/24
• DoorDash order
I hav been a patron of this place for years. Just ordered a Fried Chicken Jack and it was quite feanky the worst sandwich ive ever had. The chicken was razor thin, overcooked as hell and frankly not even edible. The bread was also a disaster. The Italian was equally miserable. Honestly not sure how they managed to mess it up so bad.
