The New Yorker Sandwich was HUGE and delicious. Bagel was fresh and toasted perfecty.
J
Jennifer Eve D
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Loved
• 4/16/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered these for the staff on my unit at the hospital this morning. I asked to have the bagels cut in case some people only wanted a half of a bagel. I appreciate that they were all cut as requested. They were slightly warm when they arrived which meant they were quite fresh. That was wonderful, especially since the order was delivered. The staff said the bagels tasted fresh and smelled good. I've taken neighbors to Eastdale bagels for breakfast and spent mornings sitting outside enjoying a bagel and a coffee with my pup. This is the best bagel shop in Poughkeepsie. I'm from Brooklyn, I know good bagels ;)
J
Jennifer Eve D
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Liked
• 5/4/26
• DoorDash order
I love there bagels. I'm from Brooklyn and they're the best bags I've found in the area. Today I ordered a Veggie Cream Cheese Quarter and it was in a side sauce cup. This is not an appropriate amount for nearly $4.
I ordered recently from here for work and got a half a pound of the cream cheese and the container was a half a pound. There are containers for deli side that are bigger than the side I received today and small even a half a pound which should have been a quarter pound. I do not recommend getting cream cheese from them. The price is bad as gas prices right now.
J
Jessica S
6 contributions
Loved
• 12/7/25
• DoorDash order
Eastdale Bagels is the best! The bagels are perfect combo of soft and firm. The staff is friendly. The only place to get breakfast in my opinion.
H
Heather N
Emerging Expert • 38 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/17/26
• DoorDash review
This is the second time they did not follow directions to please separate the everything bagels from the rest of them, especially since their menu offers a check box to separate and you note it in the comments. I also hate the fact that they substitute food without warning! Red velvet cookies are disgusting and are not the same as chocolate chip cookies.
