Eddie's Italian Eatery
4.6(3k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.6(3k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
12" Medium The Works Pizza
$27.95
•98% (51)
14" Large Milano Pizza
$33.95
16" XL Lotsa-Meatsa Pizza
$39.95
16" XL Vegetarian Pizza
$37.95
14" Large Vegetarian Pizza
$31.95
14" Large Bada-Bing Pizza
$32.95
Reviews3k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
A
Arleen S
Local Expert • 135 contributionsLiked
• 7/3/26They were a little short on the toppings this time, but overall the Pesce Bianco is a good dish. I exchange the regular pasta with multi-grain penne to keep the carbs and sugar spikes down which makes it much healthier. I appreciate the portion size, the taste, the freshness, and that there is an option to order multigrain pasta for those of us who are health-conscious. I will definitely order it again but not as often as I used to because of their ridiculously high prices which I don't think our fair. I feel they took advantage of Covid to keep their prices high while other restaurants are not gouging their customers. Given that this is middle of the road, Italian food and nothing high-level, the value isn't worth their prices, but again, it's solid if you're looking for a middle of the road Italian food.
C
Carole R
Local Expert • 41 contributionsLiked
• 4 days agoSalmon alla Griglia (550 Calories) was not nearly as good as I'd hoped for. The spinach was bland, the white beans were sparse and lacking in flavor (despite the under-cooked slices of garlic) and there was no crust on the salmon. They've made it much better before. Not worth $24.95 this time and won't try it again. I wish I had ordered something else. The Fries were nicely crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. Fountain Coke was refreshing, home made bread and salted butter was just enough but it didn't make up for what the main course was lacking. Somebody needs to learn to cook better.
A
Amy K
81 contributionsLoved
• 7/21/23Love their food! Best blue cheese dressing everywhere! Only wish the to go bruschetta had more of the vinegar and cheese - one teaspoon of each isnt enough or worth the money.
A
Amy K
81 contributionsLoved
• 7/21/23One of our all time fave places!! The Chicken Fonduta was delicious an lots of mushrooms!! The Garlic Puff is so tasty!! House Salad is always yummy !
A
Ashley R
2 contributionsLoved
• 4/24/24I will be ordering from here or going there more often!!! The food and dessert was AMAZING!!! One of the best Tiramisu I've had. The Fettuccine Paradiso was mouthwatering. Would order again. Can't wait to try more!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
July Monthly Specials
Appetizers
Soups & Salads
Specialty Salads
Pasta! Classic Sauces
Pasta! House Favorites
Pasta! Stuffed
Pasta! Baked
Pasta! Seafood & Risotto
Pizza (Combos)
Pizza (Build Your Own "NY" Style)
Our Pizza Dough is Made in House Daily and is Aged a Min. 24 Hours Prior to Cooking. This Allows the Yeast Spores to Develop the Dough & Make it Delizioso!
Pizza (Build Your Own "Detroit" Style)
Housemade Sicilian Thick Crust Pizza with Crispy, Chewy, Cheesy Edges Served with Wisconsin Brick Cheese and Mozzarella Blend.