El Maguey Mexican Restaurant
4.8(500+)ā¢
DashPassā¢
Mexican-Tex-Mexā¢
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(500+)ā¢
$$ā¢Mexican-Tex-Mex
All Day Menu
11:00āÆam - 10:20āÆpmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
El Toriado
$13.50
ā¢95% (20)
Pollo con Queso
$11.99
ā¢95% (23)
Fajita Mix
$15.50
Chicken Fajitas
$14.50
Cheese Dip
$4.25+
ā¢92% (51)
#1 Most liked
Street Tacos
$12.25
ā¢100% (10)
Reviews500+ ratings ā¢ 10+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
J
Jasmine F
5 contributionsLoved
ā¢ 3/3/25The supreme nachos are amazing everytime. And I love the soft shell beef tacos. The quntity and flavor is definitely worth the price.
H
H K
1 contributionsLoved
ā¢ 9/27/23The meat can be a bit dry, and I've gotten some tough steak before, but overall this is the best Mexican restaurant in Maryville, and I'm always happy to get food from here.
Delivery drinks are a big size, they listen to your special instructions, and things are packaged nicely so they don't fall out. You also get a good amount of salsa and chips for 1-2 people.
S
Sabrina S
6 contributionsLoved
ā¢ 5/28/26The Guacamole Dip is always fresh and yummy. The Fajitas Mix is my go to order, and the single is huge! I can never finish it in one sitting.
Greggory G
7 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 6/22/26they put a lot less portion of Fajitas Volcan toppings then usual barely any refried beans and avocado and the rice was hard/uncooked
A
April M
1 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 2/7/26We normally love El Maguay but something was very off about our food this time. We ordered an 8oz cheese and 8oz salsa and both tasted awful! We couldn't decide if it was a metal taste or what but it was so bad we couldn't eat any of it. The meals weren't quite as bad but they definitely tasted off as well. Pretty disappointed when we paid a lot of money for our food.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
SPECIAL
FAMILY PACK
Steaks
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, seafood or eggs may increase the risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Tacos
Appetizers
Nachos
Drinks
Quesadillas
Soups & Salads
Special EntrƩes
Burritos
Chicken
Seafood
Fajitas
All of our fajitas are cooked with onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes and served with rice, fried beans, lettuce, guacamole, sour cream, pico de gallo, and (3) tortillas.
Dinner Combinations
All combos are served with rice and beans. Choice of meats: beef, shredded chicken, cheese, beans, and pork.
Enchiladas
Kids Menu
Drink included.