Like most good stories, ours begins at the bar. First, there were drinks. The drinks led to pizza. But a big night of drinks and pizza often leads to biscuits in the morning. Not your average biscuits…
Mmmk. Where do I start. Everything at Fat Sully's is good. Like really really, really good. I do a little dance every time we decide to order it. It's a pizza place and yet their cheeseburger is one of my favorite burgers, anywhere. Their pizza is also... incredible. It's unctuous and chewy and yum. Their loaded garlic knots are, otherworldly. The waffle fries, delightful. My only tiny critique is that they use bread & butter pickles for their burgers and don't offer dill :/ But please, do yoself a favor, and order from here!
D
Dan S
Local Expert • 51 contributions
Loved
• 3/11/26
• DoorDash order
The Lights Out Burger (Double) was incredibly tasty, in my opinion one of the best in town. It was fresh, hot and larger than I expected. The Waffle Fries were also good and plentiful. I'll definitely be ordering again.
K
Karley B
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/10/26
• DoorDash order
Wasn't terrible but wasn't great. Definitely not worth the price they're asking in my opinion. Tough limp crust and Skimpiest pepperoni distribution ever. Trying all the pizza joints in the area and def not ordering here again. Lowest of the "ny pizza" I've had in co.
A
Adam H
2 contributions
Liked
• 12/9/25
• DoorDash order
Fat Sully's is the gold standard of pizza in this area. However, over the past year their Caesar Salad has gone up in price but has probably halved in size, so I would not recommend it.
Pizza is amazing though and I will always order that.
S
Shannan B
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/31/24
• DoorDash order
We ordered 2 12" gluten free pizzas, and they were outstanding! The crust was perfect and the pizza sauce was the best I've had. They were also very generous with the pizza sauce and the toppings! I highly recommend! This is my new go to pizza!
