Overall, I'd say it's a solid choice if you're looking for a quick and satisfying meal. I'd give it 4.5 stars out of 5. While it may not be the pinnacle of pizza perfection, I wouldn't hesitate to order it again.
Good cheese, good sauce,great 16" X Large NY Cheese Pizza (Build Your Own)10 slices .
E
Elyse J
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/28/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering from Fat Tomato, and I was very confused to receive a pizza with the cheese placed on top of the toppings. I called the shop, and they confirmed they do this only for pizzas with vegan cheese as a way to indicate to customers that it's vegan. Pretty much every other restaurant simply marks the box with a "V" to indicate vegan, so this was super strange to me, and the quality suffered as a result. The pizza was soggy from the cheese being on top, and there wasn't much of the toppings underneath (I got half peppers/onions and half roasted garlic/sundried tomatoes) so it tasted like just eating overly cheesy bread. I chose this place because of the price and the menu photos showing a ton of toppings. But vegans beware. I wont be ordering from here again.
D
Drew V
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 1/21/26
• DoorDash order
I get the Oven-baked wings and either a NY Cheese Pizza or the barbecue chicken pizza, both are good.
This is my go to spot for wings because they put a bunch in there, and they're super fresh and hot.
I'll also dip the pizza in the hot wing sauce, classic move by me.
I get this place all the time.
A
Adam M
3 contributions
Loved
• 5/19/23
• DoorDash order
First time eating here. Well priced pizza. We had the Signature Pizza and it was excellent. We weren't expecting much, which was nice. If you want greasy this isn't the place. Toppings were spread evenly and generous. Everything had lots of flavor. Clean, quality ingredients were noticeable.
R
Raine F
Local Expert • 22 contributions
Liked
• 1/6/26
• DoorDash order
theAll Pepperoni Pizza was PACKED with pepperoni and delicious but super greasy so be cautious. the Fat Garlic Knots (Signature) were supergood and fresh but the marinara was incredible. I could drink it. I got extra on accident and will be putting it on anything
