Finelli New York Pizzeria
4.5(1k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(1k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
10:30 am - 9:35 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Maine Summer Pie!
$19.99
Cheese Pizza (18")
$21.49
•82% (39)
Bianca
$17.99
•92% (57)
#1 Most liked
Supreme
$17.99
•87% (8)
Cheese Pizza (14")
$17.69
•84% (25)
Cheese Pizza (12")
$14.29
•92% (38)
#2 Most liked
Reviews1k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
A
Amy C
1 contributionsLiked
• 6/30/26Always have good meals from them. Their portions have gotten much smaller in recent years, so I can't rave about value (esp. desserts~ really tiny for the $$), but the quality is always good. Fresh ingredients, homemade breads, and they always get the order correct (which IS a big deal).
A
Allie S
6 contributionsDidn't like
• 2/14/25Italian sandwich was awesome, on focaccia bread. the pizza was rubbery and cold, the garlic knots were tiny, burnt, and to hard to bite into. disappointed to spend 60 bucks and only 1 items was any good, maybe an off night for them?
O
Olivia B
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/14/22Turkey blt has bacon bits for the bacon, just doesn’t have a great flavor and it all falls out of the sandwich. Not a lot of turkey on it either for the price. Focaccia bread had a good flavor, but not really what you want on a turkey club.
D
Dan B
10 contributionsLoved
• 8/3/25The Carnivorous Rex pizza was amazing, great char on the crust and flavorful all around. I added mushrooms and Kalamata olives. The Italian sub on the rub roll was the best sub I've had some moving to Maine! Reminded me of the subs I grew up eating in southeast Pennsylvania.
D
Dan B
10 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/17/23Carnivorous Rex was a little underdone, but no problem just warmed it up in the oven and it's great. 99 Cent Wing Extravaganza! Weren't crispy and I only got 5 when I paid for 6. Also no dipping sauce, glad I had some in my fridge.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Monthly Specials
Specialty Menu Items of the Month
Pasta & Soups
Homemade pasta and soup dishes!
Slices
18” pizza slices
Appetizers
Pizzas
You can order your pizza one of three ways: 1. Half baked take it home and make it fresh from your oven 2. Standard bake - golden brown 3. Oven char-baked with a crunch.
Specialty Red Pies
Specialty White Pies
Calzones
Calzones
Cold Subs
Cold subs.
Hot Subs
Hot subs.
Salads
Add chicken to any salad for additional charge. Dressings: Italian, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Southwest Ranch, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, and Greek
Chips
Soft Drinks
Coca-Cola Products