Without a doubt one of the best restaurants in the Mohawk Valley, I would go as far as saying that several of their items definitely rank among the top for "best ordering decision/choice" choice in the great central New York. Their portion size is more often than not enough for two people. There are no surprises whatever you choose will be consistent time after time, regardless of who is in the kitchen preparing entrees. The review wouldn't be complete without commenting, on their famous Sicilian style pizza, it's absolutely delicious.
L
Lynn A
21 contributions
Liked
• 2/18/26
• DoorDash order
After many, many trials, I feel I've finally found a pizza that reminds me of authentic New York City pizza. Their large, hand-tossed pizza has a tasty crust, fantastic sauce, rich and robust, and quality cheese. The taste is consistent, every time. The slices are full and generous, eight per large pie.
Fratello's has spoiled me....all other pizza pales in comparison!
L
Lori T
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Loved
• 8/17/25
• DoorDash order
I had the steak and Steak and Mozzarella Large Sub on garlic bread. It was perfect. It was nice and hot and full of meat, cheese, and great seasoning. It was my first time trying their fries. They are coated and full of flavor. The boys had the pizza and they said it was perfect. Always a great meal from here. I will definitely order again.
L
Lori T
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Liked
• 12/2/25
• DoorDash order
This was our first time trying the Scicilian Large Sicilian Pizza(Pan), and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly done and no burning on the bottom. There was just the right amount of sauce which tasted delicious. A great layer of cheese melted to a light golden brown. Plenty of pizza for 3 of us to enjoy and have leftovers. It was nice and fresh and arrived hot. Great experience.
S
Sara M
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
I waited 45 mins for my food to be done. When I got home the broccoli were small little pieces I could barely see instead of the florets. And I don't know why they put onions in the Alfredo but not everyone likes them. Very dissatisfied with my order
