2nd time ordering and trying Gandolfo's. The Macaroni and cheese arrived hot ! The 6 in little Italy was good The bread fresh. The Banana Pudding is awesome 2nd time ordering it. Haven't tried the egg salad yet. I will order again
B
Bonnie S
Local Expert • 405 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/30/26
• DoorDash order
NOT like the taste of a NEW YORK Rueben ...the pastrami and corned beef taste and texture were more like Arby's. The rye bread was also wrong for New York style. I admit, I was not expecting Carneige Deli or Katz's on Delancy... Boise isn't even close...
S
Stephanie H
6 contributions
Liked
• 3/10/24
• DoorDash order
The food all tasted great, but the pickle spears' juice leaked out of the paper and made everything else in the bag soggy. I would recommend different packaging for the pickles. They were out of the pasta salad I ordered; the potato salad they replaced it with (thank you!) was good, but I was craving pasta salad. The macaroni and cheese was excellent- super cheesy. The sandwich's flavor was excellent, but soggy from the pickle juice that leaked throughout the entire bag. Also, it was very small for a $18 sandwich. The only other (big) negative beside the size of the sandwich was the bun to hot dog ratio for all the hot dogs. Wayyyy too much bun. A regular sized hot dog does not need a big hoagie roll. Flavors were really good, but not sure if it's worth the money. Maybe for a splurge when craving it. A few tweaks to sizing, pricing and packaging and it would definitely be 5 stars.
T
Tanya S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/6/23
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delish! The hero bread is so fresh and soft! The only issue is the New Yorker was to have double meats (2 kinds I think) and it only had a VERY small amount of 1 meat. Tasty but not worth $22
B
Bobbe B
Emerging Expert • 87 contributions
Liked
• 5/16/26
• DoorDash order
Hot dog was very good. The sandwich however, only had a little bit of turkey in the very center and two small pieces of avocado that were both brown. The bread was really good though.
