2nd time ordering and trying Gandolfo's. The Macaroni and cheese arrived hot ! The 6 in little Italy was good The bread fresh. The Banana Pudding is awesome 2nd time ordering it. Haven't tried the egg salad yet. I will order again
S
Stephanie H
6 contributions
Liked
• 3/10/24
• DoorDash order
The food all tasted great, but the pickle spears' juice leaked out of the paper and made everything else in the bag soggy. I would recommend different packaging for the pickles. They were out of the pasta salad I ordered; the potato salad they replaced it with (thank you!) was good, but I was craving pasta salad. The macaroni and cheese was excellent- super cheesy. The sandwich's flavor was excellent, but soggy from the pickle juice that leaked throughout the entire bag. Also, it was very small for a $18 sandwich. The only other (big) negative beside the size of the sandwich was the bun to hot dog ratio for all the hot dogs. Wayyyy too much bun. A regular sized hot dog does not need a big hoagie roll. Flavors were really good, but not sure if it's worth the money. Maybe for a splurge when craving it. A few tweaks to sizing, pricing and packaging and it would definitely be 5 stars.
T
Tanya S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/6/23
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delish! The hero bread is so fresh and soft! The only issue is the New Yorker was to have double meats (2 kinds I think) and it only had a VERY small amount of 1 meat. Tasty but not worth $22
K
Kimberly S
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/8/26
• DoorDash order
All the lettuce and avacado were brown. The only thing fresh tasting was the tomato and the side salad. They should probably empty their lettuce and avacado and make fresh. Generally a pretty good place but not today
B
Bobbe B
Emerging Expert • 87 contributions
Liked
• 5/16/26
• DoorDash order
Hot dog was very good. The sandwich however, only had a little bit of turkey in the very center and two small pieces of avocado that were both brown. The bread was really good though.
