Delicious Large Tomato Pie . The crust is crispy and light, nice char and the sauce is well balanced. The meatballs are fantastic too! So tender. This is my new fav pizza spot
J
Jessica I
1 contributions
Loved
• 4/4/26
• DoorDash review
I grew up in Trenton (Villa Park) in the 80s and every time I would sleep over at my grandmom's house, we would get a well-done mushroom and onion pie from Gervasio's. For the uninitiated, they used to be in the same building where Killarney's is now. To say that I grew up right between the two infamous Trenton Tomato Pie joints and STILL preferred Gervasio's time and time again is a true testament to how good their pie is. When I saw that they had come back from the dead, I was floored. It was like winning the food lottery. The pie is EXACTLY the same, with beautiful little crispy bubbles all over the crust. Everything else I have had from here is has been fantastic and I am so comforted that they are back to slinging fantastic food once again. I will never stop ordering and I truly wish them the best of luck with this iteration of a classic. Love you guys!
M
Meaghan E
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/12/24
• DoorDash order
This is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The texture and flavor of the crust is perfect. The tomato and cheese complement the crust so well.
L
Lisa M
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/15/24
• DoorDash order
Very disappointing .... overcooked; chewy dough; Did not taste like fresh mozzarella; Did not taste like any other margueritta pie ive had. Basil charred.
Meatballs dry not much flavor.
S
Sarah C
Emerging Expert • 58 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/5/24
• DoorDash review
pasta was good, but didn't have enough sauce. also needs more garlic or onions in the base of the sauce. salad was DISGUSTING! the lettuce consisted of only the very top parts of the romaine. too green and brown and wilted
