Godofredo's Pizzeria & Tap Room is a family owned Italian gastropub located in the heart of Cushing's Broadway District and is connected to The Historic Dunkin Theatre built in 1926. After the earthq…
In my opinion they make the best pizza in Cushing, and I am more than happy to support a locally-owned business. Despite my (small) complaints with my last order, overall, given my experience with them, as a business they deserve 5 stars. Would definitely recommend.
That said...
If you order basil, 90% of the time they sub it with oregano (I think) or leave it off completely. But given it's only 50¢ I'm not worried about it. Also if you get fresh garlic be warned it's REALLY strong, even for an avid garlic-lover like myself.
Last pizza I ordered (pictured) the crust was slightly burnt, and while I did order it par-baked, the last par-baked one I ordered was NOT burnt. But let's be honest I still ate almost the whole thing in one sitting. Their crust is phenomenal even when a little black on the edges, and even though it looks really dark it honestly didn't taste that way. The texture was still perfect. This is the only time I've had this problem.
Utterly delighted that they offer dairy-free cheese, even though it seems they only have a "cheddar" variety. Lots of options for toppings.
Pictured: BYOPie - Build Your Own Pizza with 14" par-baked crust, house sauce, dairy-free cheese, sun-dried tomato, "basil" (again I'm pretty sure it's actually oregano)
J
J M
3 contributions
Loved
• 1/19/25
• DoorDash order
First time trying this wonderful pizzeria, I'm ordering again today. I'll add more to the next review, I'll have more information concerning the menu. But it was a great job, tasty and delivered very quickly. Thank you. BEASterita, if you like something a little sweeter. The BEASt loved it, added banana peppers and extra cheese. Fantastic.
Katelyn M
4 contributions
Loved
• 1/1/26
• DoorDash order
I have been ordering the Pookins Tortellini, since you guys opened consistently. It is definitely my go-to. Always consistant! Oh, and pro tip add an extra side of pesto cream to pour extra on top... delish! Also, dont worry about not having enough food!
Katelyn M
4 contributions
Loved
• 5/18/25
• DoorDash order
VERY generous serving! The photo is after I devoured half of it! Great flavor and fresh, even though it was close to closing!
E
Evan G
1 contributions
Liked
• 3/14/26
• DoorDash order
The tiramisu was really good but definitely a bit overpriced for the portion. When I opened the container I was left with a feeling of "that's all I got?"
