The best New York style bagels west of NY...brought to you by an actual New Yorker! Baked fresh & HOT all day! We sell bagels by the dozen, a wide variety of egg sandwiches, pastrami to die for, the …
I consider myself a bagel and cream cheese fanatic. I ordered a bagel cream cheese and I ordered one with cream cheese and bacon. One bite into it I was shocked. I have never tasted a bagel this good in my life. And the cream cheese added to my delight. Try it you won't be disappointed.
A
Amanda C
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Loved
• 10/18/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered 1 Baker's Dozen Bagels and they arrived fresh and still hot. These are the closest to real NY bagels that you can find in Boise. The honey pistachio cream cheese is the best
M
Mckinley R
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
Loved
• 5/29/24
• DoorDash order
My wife and I are HUGE bagel people. We are also very picky about our bagels. If I could give this place a 10 star I would. I am absolutely obsessed with the garlic Cream Cheese and the Everything Pumpernickel Bagel. What a combo!
C
Camy D
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 8/16/24
• DoorDash order
They say first impressions are everything and Goldstein's did not dissapoint! The smell that came out of my bag of bagels upon delivery was mouthwatering. The I Am A I am a Prince (I'll Have it All) was so incredible; I had it on the everything bagel and it was perfection! My only tiny "room for improvement" comment is that I wish they had packaged my cinnamon raisin bagel separately because it vaguely smells of onion and garlic. I'm sure it'll still be fabulous, but it would be nice to try without the interfering flavor profiles.
X
X Z
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/26/24
• DoorDash order
The thinnest layer of ham on this sandwich, a very un-generous amount. It doesn't match the picture of that high-piled ham they have listed, at all. I have received a few orders now with stingy amounts of lox. Its hit or miss as of late, usually a miss. I want to love this place, but will need to move on if the value and love that goes into the sandwiches doesn't improve. I'm a good customer too -a spend of probably at least $500 over the past year, which is why I'm taking the time -I want to keep coming. Here's hoping for improvement. Thank you.
