the WINGS (6PC) were absolutely amazing! they had a nice bit of a smoky taste that made them taste like they were fresh off the grill and they're a decent size too.the CHEESE PIZZA (10')has fresh ingredients and i loved the taste of the crush. I'll definitely be ordering again in the future and I'm glad this location opened up near here!
S
Shelly D
9 contributions
Loved
• 5/14/26
• DoorDash order
Chicken parm sandwich was SO good! Fries were kinda meh, could use more salt or seasoning. The chicken Caesar salad was big and a great value.
Tina C
Local Expert • 62 contributions
Loved
• 4/17/26
• DoorDash order
Everything was so delicious, hot, and fresh, and I got more than enough to last until the next day. I got a PERSONAL PAN (8') with spinach and mozzarella, COMBO STROMBOLIS with mozzarella spinach and seasoned beef (this was my favorite 😍), which came with a nice SIDE GARDEN SALAD with Caesar dressing. I also got the WINGS (6PC) fried crispy with a SM FRENCH FRIES and blue cheese.
This was definitely a treat and my new go-to restaurant when I want to order out.
The only thing is I would appreciate if they could put the PERSONAL PAN (8') in a bag or secure it some kind of way. The lid was a bit lifted and it was on the ground. I just feel like anything could have gotten inside of it or any person could have opened it up.
Otherwise, perfect. Thanks Goodfella's!
K
Kimberly E
5 contributions
Loved
• 12/4/25
• DoorDash order
I got my daughter a personal pan pizza. She loved it. It was very cheesy, and had a lot of pepperoni on it. For my son, I got a Stromboli and it was HUGE and absolutely stuffed with cheese. I got a gyro meal, and was very surprised with the portion size of the meat, there was so much on it! It was absolutely delicious, and the fries were seasoned, fresh, and crispy! Overall, I will be ordering from here again, and will be going in person for myself sometime!
A
Anthony R
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/8/26
• DoorDash order
i tried Goodfellas and honestly wasn’t impressed. The wings were really small and barely had any sauce on them. On top of that, they had a weird smell, which made it hard to enjoy them.
The pizza was also disappointing—there was barely any sauce, so it tasted dry and bland. The Philly cheesesteak wasn’t much better either; the bread was kind of burnt and threw off the whole sandwich.
The fries were okay, probably the only thing I didn’t have an issue with.
Overall, the food just didn’t hit. Between the lack of flavor, poor preparation, and quality issues, I wouldn’t go back.
