OMG, this is absolutely the BEST pizza, and the Garlic Bread 3 Pieces is to die for!! Better than the Milwaukee pizza joints I have traveled to. The pizza had plenty of cheese, I ordered extra 14" Cheese but certainly not necessary. Only place Ill be frequenting, this is my new and only place in the future!
B
Brittany P
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/12/23
• DoorDash review
We used to live down the road from Gordys and would walk down to pick it up. Owners and staff are very friendly and the pizza is amazing every single time! They load up the toppings and the crust has a perfect crunch! We moved to a different town so I was very excited when Gordys popped up on DoorDash, we had it for dinner tonight and it was delicious!
R
Rachel B
9 contributions
Loved
• 4/5/26
• DoorDash order
Got a14" sausage pizza, as always, it did not disappoint! I have ordered this pizza multiple times and no one makes it better than them! I'm going to keep ordering from them for sure. Everything was hot and fresh, and the slices were squares but they were pretty big squares
E
Elly B
55 contributions
Loved
• 5/13/25
• DoorDash order
Oh my goodness, this was easily the BEST lunch I've ever had. The Cheese Bread 1 Piece was buttery, flakey, garlicky, and perfectly cooked and the cheese on top was full of flavor and AMAZING. The 12" Unstuffed Popper pizza is now going to be my favorite pizza. The thin crust, and the sauce are to die for. I love it!
D
Desiree H
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Loved
• 10/18/25
• DoorDash order
Garlic Bread 3 Pieces you could taste garlic through every single bite
12" Deluxe (Fresh Mushrooms) had just enough toppings to go pretty much all the way through every single bite
Pepperoncini Slices if I would have known that big of the cup I would have just got a one but it was very fresh
Overall the portion sizes great for me and my little one
I most definitely would order again whenever I come back to Wisconsin
