The S'mores cookie is the house favorite. They take a long time because they make them to order, so we don't mind at all! We order earlier to have them in time for when we actually need them and they are always fresh and warm! They do a wonderful job with the cookies, they're amazing! Service suggestion would be a call or text saying your order was delivered, but I don't fault them.
J
Jennifer S
Emerging Expert • 21 contributions
Loved
• 12/24/25
• DoorDash order
Yes they are expensive. But honey worth every penny. I got the Chocolate Chip Brownie, the Chocolate Chunk Blondie, and the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Deluxe. Cost me almost $20 can't remember if that was with or without tip. But keep in mind the brownie and blondie are delux not regular cookies. And they were HUGE. I was literally on phone talking to insomnia because there was a mix up with driver. Not their fault but as we were talking the order showed up and I took a bite of the blondie while I was still on phone. I literally mumbled something to manager about "it's all good" and got off phone in a hurry. ....I stopped my shower water, crawled into bed and ate all 3 without another word. Didn't even pour milk or coffee cause I was too distracted by the PURE BLISS AND HEAVENLY FLAVOR. I stopped being cranky about being stuck in hotel on work trip. I stopped being an overworked single mom. I simply became a little kid eating great cookies
So if your in Louisville try this place or Jeff's donuts (apple fritter fresh from fryer) These are literally the best 2 places to get desert in whole city.
PS I tried to press freshness too but it wouldn't let me. They were very fresh!
J
Jaye D
5 contributions
Loved
• 6/19/25
• DoorDash order
10/10 would recommend. I ordered last hour before close. Cookies were still warm and moist. I got 3 cookies, (s'mores was top tier) The merchant delivered. Great experience overall :)
L
Leslie I
9 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/14/24
• DoorDash order
The cookies are fine, not great not bad. They are small for the price you pay. Maybe 3" wide. 6 cookies before tip was $25. Too much for what you get.
N
Nancy B
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/14/26
• DoorDash order
It was a good tasting cookie but it was absolutely not worth the price. This was my 1st time ordering. They were very small cookies for the price. I can't justify paying that much $$ for a 12 pack of small cookies.
