Jeremiah's Italian Ice
4.8(500+)•
DashPass•
Ice Cream & Gelato•
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(500+)•
$$•Ice Cream & Gelato
Since 1996, Jeremiah's Italian Ice has been serving you delectable frozen delicacies. Our Italian Ice is a delicious yet refreshing dessert that packs a punch of flavor. Our Ice flavors cover a wide r…
Full Menu
12:00 pm - 8:45 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Birthday Cake Jelati Cake
$26.99$35.99
25% off
6 Pack - Ice Cream Sandwiches
$13.49$17.99
25% off
Quart Jelati
$11.09
•100% (14)
#3 Most liked
Medium Jelati
$6.89
•96% (27)
#1 Most liked
Quart Italian Ice
$9.89
•92% (13)
Large Jelati
$8.09
•100% (20)
#2 Most liked
Reviews500+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
J
Jennifer M
6 contributionsLoved
• 4/16/23The best frozen dessert in Tallahassee. The cookie butter gelati with vanilla ice cream is delicious. The Scoop Frog gelati with chocolate ice cream is glorious! The atmosphere inside the store is so much fun. I love the old school jams playing while enjoying the tasty treats with friends. The crew is fantastic. The store manager is awesome. Highly recommend Jeremiah's Italian Ice.
C
Charles D
Emerging Expert • 13 contributionsLiked
• 1/24/26Jeremiah's never disappoints! Regardless of location, it is consistently delicious every time. All of their sweet treats are amazing, and they certainly give you your money's worth. Plus, their staff are always very kind, courteous, and helpful. They are my favorite 'cheat day' indulgence that I'll order time and time again!
J
Jennifer M
6 contributionsLoved
• 11/28/22The best soft ice cream on the planet! The Gelati is a mixture of the Italian Ice layered with their delicious soft ice cream. The Italian ices are fantastic by themselves, so is the ice cream.
What makes Jeremiah's the best frozen dessert is the Gelati. The cookie butter ice with vanilla ice cream plus cookie butter crumbles is to die for. The Mango italian ice plus vanilla ice cream if another favorite.
If you like chocolate try the scoop frog and the cookies and cream gelatis. You will love it!
J
Jennifer M
6 contributionsLiked
• 1/18/26The Hop Away Ice Cream Sandwich was awesome! Love the Jelati's as well. Would definitely order again. Best frozen dessert treats in Tallahassee!!
K
Kai H
18 contributionsLoved
• 4/2/23Best Italian ice place EVER. They noticed I was a frequent buyer and gave me a free one on the house!!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Flavorites
Ice Cream Sandwiches
The perfect handheld treat on-the-go!
Jelati Cakes
LIMIT ONE CAKE PER ORDER
Ices and Jelatis
Extras
Enticing Add-ons!