Fantastic! They did an excellent job with what they were given. Thank you for listening to the notes, as well. That was a fantastic Sub. Thank you!
Plenty of meat, cheese, lettuce, and additional toppings. Worked out well!
M
Melody S
Local Expert • 14 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/29/25
• DoorDash order
The tuna fish at Jersey Mike’s just isn’t it for me. Compared to my #1 favorite at Jimmy John’s (for reference only), this one really fell short. The tuna looked a little off—kind of dark—and it had a strong black pepper scent/ taste that didn’t sit right. I like pepper in my tuna, but this was overpowering in a different way. Honestly, I wouldn’t order it again.
I gave half to my kid just so it didn’t go to waste (no complaints from him, although he did mention the strong pepper scent). On the bright side, the cookie was really good—definitely a solid 4 stars for that. Overall, I’d rate the sandwich 2.5, but since halves aren’t an option, I’ll round it up to 3.
E
Elizabeth M
4 contributions
Loved
• 5/8/25
• DoorDash order
The gluten free roll was very good compared to most gluten free bread! It held together well and wasn't hard. The rest of the sub was good as well and was still warm when it was delivered.
C
Carolyn C
Emerging Expert • 60 contributions
Loved
• 12/8/22
• DoorDash review
I love #17, and this location does it just the way I want. Thank you so much!! It was hot and made to perfection.
The cold sub must have been by someone else. Not as grand.
I will order from here again in a heartbeat!
L
Linda C
13 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/16/24
• DoorDash order
I've never paid $68 for 2 subs, chips and one pop. Even 5th Tavern was only $55 for two orders and their fees! Too pricey for me!! The food was great but not at price.
