the Medium Buffalo 14" had a unique flavor profile. it was delicious.
same with Pepperoni PinWheel - it looked a little odd, but It was soooo good and it was huge.
the Cookies are like homemade and delicious!
definitely my new favorite pizza shop in the area.
J
Jorge C
Emerging Expert • 33 contributions
Loved
• 7/13/26
• DoorDash order
EXCELLENT taste. Great, fresh ingredients. The garlic knot was JUST what I needed. Amazing cheese flavor and delicious Marinara for dipping. Many other places use LOW quality. It ruins the experience. This was exactly what I needed. Hawaiian Pizza was huge and delicious. Love the peppers on top. Cookies were good too. Only thing missing? The ranch I ordered.
F
Fran M
Local Expert • 140 contributions
Loved
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
i lived in brooklyn for many years...we have always loved Italian food...since moving here to JC finding good legit Italian foid can be hit or miss...Jersey Pizza Shop is a HIT! Their sanwiches are on Homemade bread and is delicious!eggplant parm sandwich,chicken & meatball sliders,excellent...Give this place a try
A
Angel S
4 contributions
Liked
• 3/6/26
• DoorDash order
The Pizza is way smaller than expected for the price, they even put a piece of aluminum foil to compensate that the box being bigger than the pizza. Too little ricotta cheese on the pizza also, unlike the picture suggests.
S
Scott W
2 contributions
Loved
• 3/22/26
• DoorDash order
I read other reviews and decided to try Jersey Pizza Shop. It's close by in the McGinley Square neighborhood of Jersey City. The store is small but does have several tables for dine-in. It's a newer store - clean and professionally run. Enjoyed the Vinnie’s Italian Sausage pizza. It was a special - Buy 1 medium get 1 free. Such a deal! An absolutely perfectly delicious crust! Bite after bite, the pizza had great flavor and tasted fresh. Great tasting sauce - and not drowning in sauce. And the sausage was quite tasty too. The pizza tasted like someone actually made it just before I arrived to pick it up -- not two days ago, and not frozen. Also enjoyed two Choco Chunk cookies. Those were fresh and delicious - a cross between soft and chewy and slightly crunchy on the edges. Yummy!
I will be back. And I would highly recommend
